On Easter Sunday in 1948, 57 people gathered in the “Upper Room” of a house which was located on Larkin Street, near the present Fellowship Hall. Of those present, 26 became the first members of the West Side Community Church. Its charter remained open until it registered 100 members, and the name was changed to Westside Community Methodist Church.

This house and another, affectionately known as the “Coach House” (because of its original use as an inn) were located on a three acre plot of land then on the far west side of Madison. The two buildings once housed the YWCA Summer Camp and the Kiddie Camp.

In 1951, the church changed its name to Bethany Methodist Church. The first new building to be erected on the property was a multi-purpose building, Fellowship Hall, which was completed in December 1952. Bethany continued its rapid growth, and to accommodate the needs of the congregation, completed the sanctuary in 1957.

A booklet published on the first anniversary of the congregation states, “It was not a proud church in material things – there was no stained glass, no organ – there was little about the old frame building, in need of paint and repair, to inspire the passer-by to admiration. But there was a devout and earnest congregation, with a place to worship – the essentials of a church. Those attending that first service saw their hopes for a church stir to life, and they determined to nurture it to a powerful Christian tree.” Those hopes and determinations have continued to be significant characteristics of the congregation as members have reached out into the community and the world with significant ministries.

In 1998, Bethany celebrated its 50th anniversary. The observance started on Easter Sunday and continued for the next eight weeks. The culmination was a dinner the first week in June, for many former pastors, former members and current members. Following the dinner, there was a pops concert by the bell choir and the chancel choir.

Extensive remodeling in 1995, created new offices, a Chapel, a new entrance and handicap access throughout the building.

Those 57 people in 1948 laid a strong foundation that has enabled this church to prosper and flourish well into its next 50 years.

Many pastors have served Bethany over the years. Rev. Robert Adams was hired as the first fulltime pastor. He served until 1961. The current pastor is Rev. Brad Mather who came to Bethany in July 2004.